Skip to main content

How to Get Insurance to Cover Neuropsychological Evaluation After a Concussion

In short

To get your plan to cover a neuropsychological evaluation after a concussion, ask your treating clinician to refer you and document why you need it before the request is sent. Plans often look for thinking problems that last past the usual recovery time and results that will change your care. If denied, appeal with that proof.

Neuropsychological evaluation assesses numerous areas of brain functioning to identify problems that may not be observable with biomarkers such as neuroimaging or blood tests. A neuropsychologist looks at memory, attention, reasoning and other thinking skills, and often mood too. This type of assessment can be useful for many different types of brain health issues, including suspected head injury (APA: Concussions and how a neuropsychologist helps).

It is not the same as a quick concussion screen or a computerized test such as a baseline test. Health plans often treat those differently. Plans often require prior authorization for a neuropsychological evaluation. This guide explains what plans usually look for, how to get the request right, and what to do if the evaluation is denied. It is part of the Coverage & Appeals Center.

Concussion specialty care vs. a neuropsychological evaluation

Two kinds of specialist care can follow a concussion. They usually come at different times and answer different questions.

  • Early concussion specialty care, around 1 week after the injury. More recent research supports referral to specialty care within 1 week post-injury (see “For clinicians” below). A concussion specialist can more thoroughly assess areas of dysfunction and make treatment recommendations tailored to your individual areas of difficulty and unique circumstances. These recommendations may include behavioral techniques or referrals for additional care, like vestibular therapy, vision therapy, or psychotherapy.
  • A neuropsychological evaluation when symptoms persist. Referral for extended neuropsychological evaluation with a general, outpatient neuropsychologist (one who does not specialize in concussion) may be indicated if cognitive symptoms (changes to thinking skills) and/or mood changes persist beyond the expected recovery timeline.

Not all neuropsychologists are concussion specialists, and not all concussion specialists are neuropsychologists. The rest of this guide is about getting a neuropsychological evaluation covered.

Screening tests vs. a full neuropsychological evaluation

These are three different things, and plans often pay for them differently:

  • Brief screens. Short symptom checklists or quick thinking tests, like asking if you know the date or can remember a couple of words, often done at a regular visit.
  • Computerized tests, such as baseline tests taken before a sports season and repeated after an injury.
  • Full neuropsychological evaluation. An interview and a set of tests assessing at least two cognitive domains, given by or under a neuropsychologist, sometimes lasting up to several hours, followed by a written report. Medicare’s policy for Indiana says a “neurobehavioral status exam” comes first, and the evaluation must produce a report for the clinician who referred you (CMS: LCD L34646).

Some written policies do not count brief screens as a neuropsychological evaluation. One Medicare policy lists “screening tests of cognitive function (whether paper-and-pencil or computerized)” among the uses it does not cover as testing (CMS: LCD L34646). One large insurer calls computerized testing devices unproven “for screening asymptomatic / healthy individuals” (Aetna CPB 0158). So a baseline test for a healthy athlete may not be covered, even when testing after an injury is.

Why a neuropsychological evaluation gets denied

Denials usually fall into one of these groups:

  • Not medically necessary. The records didn’t show you meet the plan’s criteria. See not medically necessary denials.
  • Educational or work purposes. The plan says the evaluation is for school or job planning, not medical care. Some policies exclude testing for “educational or vocational purposes that do not establish medical management” (CMS: LCD L34646; Aetna CPB 0158).
  • No prior authorization. Approval was required and not on file. See missing prior authorization.
  • Hour or session limits. The plan approved fewer hours than were done, or says a repeat evaluation came too soon. See visit-limit denials.

What plans usually look for

Each plan has its own written policy for neuropsychological evaluations. The criteria below are common examples, not rules for your plan. Ask your plan for its exact policy.

  • Thinking problems that last past the usual recovery time. CDC says most people with a concussion “feel better within a couple of weeks” (CDC: Symptoms of Mild TBI and Concussion). CDC’s guidance page for children says to “refer patients whose symptoms do not resolve as expected with standard care after 2 to 4 weeks,” and lists neuropsychological evaluation for cognitive impairment (CDC: Pediatric Mild TBI guidelines).
  • Results that will change your care. For example, choosing treatment, planning rehabilitation, or deciding when to return to school, work or sport. One insurer covers testing to help develop “rehabilitation and/or management strategies” (Aetna CPB 0158). Medicare’s Indiana policy covers testing that helps with “informing treatment planning” (CMS: LCD L34646).
  • A referral from your treating clinician that explains the question the evaluation should answer. Ask your plan whether its policy requires one.
  • A brain-injury reason for the evaluation. One insurer lists “assessment of neurocognitive abilities following traumatic brain injury” as a covered use (Aetna CPB 0158).
  • A reasonable number of hours. Plans may check that the hours asked for fit the question. Aetna’s policy asks that hours “not exceed the reasonable time necessary to address the clinical questions.” Medicare’s Indiana policy says a report may be requested if testing takes more than eight hours (Aetna CPB 0158; CMS: LCD L34646).

Medicare in Kentucky and Indiana

Traditional Medicare uses local policies. In Indiana, the Medicare contractor’s policy for these evaluations is LCD L34646, “Psychological and Neuropsychological Testing” (CMS: LCD L34646). In Kentucky, check with your plan or with Medicare which policy applies.

Guidelines your clinician may cite

Your clinician can cite CDC’s concussion guidance, the international consensus statement on concussion in sport, and the 2023 NICE head injury guideline, along with research on the timing of concussion care. The details are in the section for clinicians below.

For clinicians: evidence for letters of medical necessity

These sources support early specialty assessment and referral in clinical documentation, utilization review, or an appeal of denied care. All of the studies below are observational except one small preliminary trial, so they show associations; none of them sets a deadline for referral.

Early specialty care and recovery

Eagle SR, et al. (2020): time to first concussion clinic visit (key source). A retrospective study of 218 children and adolescents seen at a concussion specialty clinic compared a first visit within 7 days of injury with a first visit 8–20 days after injury. Days to first visit was the strongest predictor of recovery taking more than 30 days (odds ratio 9.8), and it remained the strongest predictor after controlling for vestibular symptoms, headache or migraine history and total symptom severity. This shows an association; it does not prove that early referral alone caused faster recovery. Citation: Eagle SR, Puligilla A, Fazio-Sumrok V, Kegel N, Collins MW, Kontos AP. Association of time to initial clinic visit with prolonged recovery in pediatric patients with concussion. J Neurosurg Pediatr. 2020;26(2):165-170. doi:10.3171/2020.2.PEDS2025 (PubMed).

Eagle SR, et al. (2023): findings linked to vestibular therapy referral. A retrospective chart review of 331 patients seen at a concussion specialty clinic found that results across the clinical assessment domains (all except neurocognitive testing) were associated with referral for vestibular therapy. Notable factors included a motor vehicle accident mechanism of injury (odds ratio 15.45), migraine history (3.25), increased headache when concentrating (1.81) and the horizontal vestibular-ocular reflex score (1.63). It supports a comprehensive, multidomain assessment over a single test or symptom report. Limitation: it examined factors associated with referral, not whether earlier referral improved outcomes. Citation: Eagle SR, Mucha A, Trbovich A, Manderino L, Elbin RJ, Collins MW, et al. Association of multidomain assessment outcomes with referral for vestibular therapy after concussion. J Athl Train. 2023;58(5):408-413. doi:10.4085/1062-6050-0032.22 (PubMed; free full text).

Kontos AP, et al. (2021): precision vestibular rehabilitation, randomized trial. A preliminary double-blind randomized controlled trial in 55 adolescents (ages 12–18) with vestibular symptoms within 21 days of a sport or recreation concussion. Over 4 weeks, the group given precision vestibular rehabilitation improved more on vestibular-ocular reflex symptom scores than the group given behavioral management. It adds treatment evidence for targeted rehabilitation when an exam finds vestibular problems; the outcomes were symptom scores, not time to recovery, and the findings are preliminary. Citation: Kontos AP, Eagle SR, Mucha A, Kochick V, Reichard J, Moldolvan C, et al. A randomized controlled trial of precision vestibular rehabilitation in adolescents following concussion: preliminary findings. J Pediatr. 2021;239:193-199. doi:10.1016/j.jpeds.2021.08.032 (PubMed).

Timing of vestibular therapy

Ahluwalia R, et al. (2021): is earlier better? A retrospective pilot study of 23 patients with sport-related concussion: 10 started vestibular therapy within 30 days of injury and 13 started later. Median time to symptom resolution was 54 days in the earlier group versus 121.5 days in the later group, and median time to return to play was 31 versus 110 days; return to learn did not differ. The study was small and retrospective, so the size of the benefit should be read cautiously. Citation: Ahluwalia R, Miller S, Dawoud FM, Malave JO, Tyson H, Bonfield CM, et al. A pilot study evaluating the timing of vestibular therapy after sport-related concussion: is earlier better? Sports Health. 2021;13(6):573-579. doi:10.1177/1941738121998687 (PubMed; free full text).

Ferry B, et al. (2023): days to vestibular therapy and return to play. A retrospective cohort study of 282 patients with sport-related concussion and vestibular dysfunction at one clinic found that each additional day between injury and the start of vestibular therapy was associated with about 2% longer time to return to play (geometric mean ratio 1.02 per day). When vestibular dysfunction is found, timely referral may avoid unnecessary delay in treatment. Citation: Ferry B, Means G, Green C, Risoli T, Martinez C, Vomer RP, et al. Early initiation of vestibular therapy following sports-related concussions: a retrospective cohort study. Cureus. 2023;15(5):e39764. doi:10.7759/cureus.39764 (PubMed; free full text).

These studies complement each other: the 2020 study supports early clinical evaluation, and the rehabilitation studies suggest that delays in targeted treatment may be associated with longer recovery.

Clinical guidelines on referral

These guidelines show that specialty referral is a recognized part of evidence-based concussion management.

  • CDC tools for adult emergency care (2023 ACEP clinical policy). “Instruct patient to follow up with their regular healthcare professional within a few days post-injury” and “Consider referral to outpatient care for patient at high risk for post-concussive syndrome.” These are CDC’s tools for the American College of Emergency Physicians’ 2023 clinical policy on adults seen in the emergency department; the referral recommendation is graded Level C (CDC: Key recommendations for adult mild TBI; ACEP clinical policy, Ann Emerg Med 2023;81(5):e63-e105).
  • CDC guideline on mild TBI in children (2018). CDC’s guidance page says to “refer patients whose symptoms do not resolve as expected with standard care after 2 to 4 weeks.” The published guideline itself (Recommendation 11B) says “within 4–6 weeks.” It lists symptom-specific care for vestibulo-ocular dysfunction, chronic headache, cognitive impairment, sleep problems and emotional problems, and says clinicians “may refer children with persisting problems related to cognitive function for a formal neuropsychological evaluation” (Recommendation 19C, Level C). Citation: Lumba-Brown A, Yeates KO, Sarmiento K, Breiding MJ, Haegerich TM, Gioia GA, et al. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention guideline on the diagnosis and management of mild traumatic brain injury among children. JAMA Pediatr. 2018;172(11):e182853. doi:10.1001/jamapediatrics.2018.2853 (CDC guidance page; full text).
  • Consensus statement on concussion in sport (Amsterdam, October 2022; published 2023). It addresses sport-related concussion (SRC). It says: “Referral to clinicians with specialised knowledge and skills in concussion management should be considered for the targeted treatment of persisting symptoms.” On persisting symptoms and how referrals are guided, it adds: “Persisting symptoms (>4 weeks across all age groups) may be pre-existing, concussion-related or both. Serial multimodal evaluation using a tool such as the SCOAT6/Child SCOAT6, and additional detailed clinical evaluations for specific symptoms (eg, headaches, dizziness, cognition) can help guide referrals. Specialist clinicians whose diagnostic assessments, clinical evaluations and treatment interventions for SRC may be of use as part of a clinician network may vary depending on the region, practice culture and local healthcare environment, and available areas of competency and expertise.” Citation: Patricios JS, Schneider KJ, Dvorak J, Ahmed OH, Blauwet C, Cantu RC, et al. Consensus statement on concussion in sport: the 6th International Conference on Concussion in Sport–Amsterdam, October 2022. Br J Sports Med. 2023;57(11):695-711. doi:10.1136/bjsports-2023-106898 (full text).
  • NICE guideline NG232, Head injury: assessment and early management (2023). Recommendation 1.10.14: “Consider referring people who have persisting problems to a clinician trained in assessing and managing the consequences of traumatic brain injury (for example, a neurologist, neuropsychologist, clinical psychologist, neurosurgeon or endocrinologist, or a multidisciplinary neurorehabilitation team).” It is a UK guideline and does not bind US plans (NICE NG232).

What to ask your clinician to document

Before the request is sent, it helps if your chart clearly shows:

  1. The date and cause of your injury.
  2. Your thinking symptoms, such as memory, focus or slowed thinking, and how long they have lasted.
  3. How the symptoms affect school, work, driving or daily life.
  4. Treatment you have already had and the result.
  5. Any earlier screens or computerized test results.
  6. The question the evaluation should answer, and how the results will change your care.

Medicare’s Indiana policy expects the record to show the diagnosis, the reason for the evaluation, the tests given and the time, and treatment recommendations (CMS: LCD L34646).

You can ask: “Does my chart show what my plan’s policy requires?” Bring a copy of the policy if you have it.

How to get a neuropsychological evaluation covered

  1. Ask whether prior authorization is needed. Call the plan or ask the neuropsychologist’s office before you schedule.
  2. Get the plan’s policy. Ask for the criteria for a neuropsychological evaluation, not just screening.
  3. Get a referral. Ask your treating clinician to explain why an evaluation is needed and what it will decide.
  4. Make sure your chart matches the policy. Symptoms, how long they’ve lasted, treatment so far and how results will be used.
  5. Check the approval details. Match the approved hours, dates and provider to what is scheduled.
  6. If denied, appeal quickly. Ask for a peer-to-peer review and file an internal appeal with your clinician’s letter.

Billing codes, in brief

A neuropsychological evaluation is billed with time-based codes. Medicare’s Indiana billing article lists codes 96116 and 96121 for the neurobehavioral status exam, 96136–96139 for giving and scoring tests, and 96146 for automated testing. It also says “a minimum of 31 minutes must be provided to report any per hour code” (CMS: Billing and Coding article A57481). Aetna’s policy also lists 96132–96133 for evaluation services (Aetna CPB 0158).

If your approval is for fewer hours than the evaluation took, ask the neuropsychologist’s office how the hours were counted.

Timelines

  • Prior authorization decision: Since January 1, 2026, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP plans must decide urgent requests within 72 hours and standard requests within 7 calendar days (CMS: CMS-0057-F fact sheet).
  • Internal appeal: generally within 180 days of the denial under the federal rule (29 CFR 2560.503-1(h)(3)(i)); in Kentucky, at least 180 days for most plans (KY DOI UM Review Guide (2026)); check your denial letter. See Kentucky and Indiana.
  • External review: generally within 4 months of the final internal denial (federal and Kentucky); 120 days in Indiana.

If your symptoms are urgent, ask for an expedited review. Use the appeal deadline calculator to count the days.

Sample appeal letter

Sample appeal letter — neuropsychological evaluation denial

[Your name]
[Your address] · [Your phone] · [Your email]

[Date]

[Plan name] — Appeals Department
[Address or fax from your denial letter]

RE: Appeal of neuropsychological evaluation denial
Member name: [Name] · Member ID: [Number]
Reference / case number: [Number]
Service requested: Neuropsychological evaluation, [number] hours
Referring clinician: [Name, credentials]
Evaluating neuropsychologist: [Name, credentials]
Date of injury: [Date]
Date of denial: [Date]

To the Appeals Department:

I am appealing your denial of the evaluation listed above. Your letter says: "[exact reason]."

I meet your criteria for a neuropsychological evaluation, [policy name or number]:
- Injury: concussion / mild traumatic brain injury on [date] — see [record, date].
- Ongoing thinking symptoms: [memory, focus, slowed thinking], present since [date] — see [record, date].
- Treatment so far: [treatment, dates, result] — see [records].
- Why the evaluation is needed now: the results will be used to [choose treatment / plan rehabilitation / guide my return to school, work or sport].
[If denied as educational or vocational:]
- This evaluation is for my medical care after a brain injury, not for school placement or job screening. My clinician's letter explains how the results will guide my treatment.
[If hours were cut:]
- The hours requested fit the questions my clinician needs answered — see the enclosed letter.

My clinician's enclosed letter explains why the evaluation is medically necessary.

Enclosed:
- Letter of medical necessity and referral from [clinician]
- Visit notes from [dates]
- Earlier screen or computerized test results from [date] (if any)
- Your denial letter

Please approve the evaluation. If you uphold the denial, please give me the specific reason, the criteria used, and the steps for external review in writing.

[If urgent:] My clinician believes delay could harm my health. I request an expedited review.

Sincerely,
[Signature]
[Printed name]

Write your appeal letter

Work through five short steps. Your letter fills in as you type. Anything you leave blank stays in [brackets] for you to fill in by hand.

Nothing you type is sent to us. It stays on your device.



Off by default. If you turn it on, your answers are kept in this browser only until you press Clear.

1. Your situation



You can copy the exact words from your letter in step 3.






This tool needs JavaScript. The sample letters are also in each Coverage & Appeals guide.

Your letter





The appeal letter builder can help you fill in the blanks.

What the process looks like

Here is how a request for a neuropsychological evaluation usually moves. Your plan may differ.

  1. Your treating clinician refers you and documents why an evaluation is needed.
  2. The neuropsychologist’s office sends the prior authorization request to your plan, including the hours planned.
  3. The plan reviews it against its policy. Many plans covered by the 2026 federal rule must decide within 7 calendar days (72 hours if urgent).
  4. The plan approves, asks for more information, or denies. A request for more information is not a denial. Respond quickly.
  5. If approved, you schedule the evaluation within the approved dates and hours.
  6. The neuropsychologist writes a report for your referring clinician, and your care plan is updated.

An example

*This is an illustrative example, not a real patient.*

Jordan, a high school junior, had a concussion in a soccer game. Six weeks later, Jordan still has trouble focusing in class and remembering what was read. Jordan’s clinician refers Jordan for a neuropsychological evaluation. The plan denies it, saying the evaluation is “educational.”

Jordan’s family asks for the plan’s policy. It excludes evaluations for school purposes that do not affect medical care. Jordan’s clinician writes a letter explaining that the results will guide Jordan’s treatment and return-to-school plan after a brain injury. The appeal includes the visit notes showing six weeks of symptoms.

The lesson: show how the evaluation will change medical care.

Questions to ask before an evaluation

  • “Does my plan need prior authorization for a neuropsychological evaluation?”
  • “Who is sending the request, and when?”
  • “Has it been approved? What is the reference number?”
  • “How many hours were approved?”
  • “Is a computerized or screening test billed separately?”
  • “What is my cost after insurance?”

Common mistakes

  • Scheduling before approval comes through. If the plan denies it later, you may owe the bill.
  • A referral that doesn’t say why. The plan needs to know what question the evaluation will answer.
  • Letting it look like a school evaluation. If the evaluation is for medical care, the chart should say so.
  • Fewer approved hours than planned. Check the approval before the evaluation day.
  • Not asking about a peer-to-peer. It can be faster than a written appeal.

What your denial letter should tell you

Since January 1, 2026, Medicare Advantage, Medicaid, CHIP and HealthCare.gov Marketplace plans must give a specific reason when they deny a prior authorization request (CMS: CMS-0057-F fact sheet). A vague reason makes an appeal harder, so it is fair to ask for more detail.

When you get a denial for an evaluation, check that the letter tells you:

  • The exact service that was denied and the date.
  • The specific reason, in words you can act on.
  • The policy or criteria the plan used. If it doesn’t, ask for a free copy (29 CFR 2560.503-1(g)(1)(v); 45 CFR 147.136(b)).
  • Your deadline to appeal and how to send it.
  • How to ask for an expedited review if it’s urgent.
  • How to ask for an external review if the internal appeal fails.

If anything is missing, call the plan, ask for it in writing, and write down the date, the name of the person you spoke with, and a reference number. To look up a code on your denial, try the denial decoder.

Injured at work or in a car crash?

Workers’ comp or auto insurance may need to pay first. See Kentucky workers’ comp, Indiana workers’ comp, or car accident medical bills: PIP and med pay.

Costs and your deductible while you wait

An appeal can take weeks. Meanwhile, it helps to understand what you might owe either way.

  • If the appeal succeeds, the plan pays under your normal benefits. You still owe any deductible, copay or coinsurance.
  • If you go ahead before a decision, you may owe the full bill if the appeal fails. Ask for a written cost estimate first.
  • Check your EOB when the claim is processed. It shows what was billed, allowed and owed.
  • Ask about payment plans if a large bill arrives during the appeal. Ask the billing office to hold the account while the appeal is open.

If coverage doesn’t work out

You still have options:

  • Ask for an external review after a final internal denial.
  • Ask about a cash-pay price and get it in writing first.
  • Ask your clinician about other next steps while you wait.

Before paying cash, ask how it affects your deductible. Cash payments may not count toward it unless your plan allows that.

Frequently asked questions

Is a neuropsychological evaluation the same as a concussion screen?

No. A screen is short. Full evaluation involves at least two tests assessing at least two areas of functioning. Plans often treat them differently.

Do I need prior authorization?

Many plans require it. Ask your plan or the neuropsychologist’s office before you schedule.

My plan says the evaluation is educational. What can I do?

Ask your clinician to explain in writing how the results will guide your medical care, then appeal.

Will my plan pay for a baseline test before a sports season?

Often not, because baseline tests are given to healthy people. Ask your plan. Testing after an injury may be covered differently.

How long does approval take?

For Medicare Advantage, Medicaid and CHIP plans, decisions are due within 72 hours for urgent requests and 7 calendar days for standard ones since 2026.

Can I appeal if I already had the evaluation?

Usually, yes. File an internal appeal with your clinician’s letter and records before the deadline.

Does Aptiva help get an evaluation approved?

For Aptiva patients, yes. Aptiva’s team handles prior authorization and appeals for our patients in Kentucky and Indiana.

Sources

Cite this page

Last updated . Reviewed by Lisa Manderino, PhD.

APA

Aptiva Health Learning Hub. (2026, October 27). How to Get Insurance to Cover Neuropsychological Evaluation After a Concussion. https://www.aptivalearninghub.com/appeals/get-covered/concussion-neuropsych-evaluation/

MLA

"How to Get Insurance to Cover Neuropsychological Evaluation After a Concussion." Aptiva Health Learning Hub, 27 Oct. 2026, www.aptivalearninghub.com/appeals/get-covered/concussion-neuropsych-evaluation/.